lichess.org
Donate

unsplash.com

A Disappointing Defeat

ChessAnalysis boardTacticsStrategy
I analysis a loss of mine that should have been a victory

https://lichess.org/study/aksQkSF9/QFRq5MpI#0

Above is the full game. I had the black pieces.

Intro

As I said in my previous post, losing a winning game is one of the most painful types of blunders in chess. Chess punishes impulsivity. I was so happy the way this game was going until the heartbreaking blunder at the end. Before I continue, I respect my opponent, since they played a good game.

Opening Analysis

When confronted with the English Opening, I usually default to the Symmetrical Variation, Two Knights Variation. I did fairly well with this and in other games, so I do not believe I ought to change this yet. Although, I have been considering e4, which could lead to the King's English, Two Knights Variation. It seems slightly better because it capitalizes on the weak d4 square. They then played a move I wasn't expecting, Qb3 (position below). It seems somewhat logical at first. It targets the d5 square and b7 pawn, preventing bishop development. However, once I realized that the queen could be chased away and that b6 would protect the b pawn and create a very nice pawn chain, I was not too worried anymore.

https://lichess.org/study/aksQkSF9/QFRq5MpI#5

After developing our minor pieces a bit, I committed a slight chess sin: moving a piece twice in the opening (Nd4). I did it for a good reason though, and the chess engine does not hate it. It attacks the pinned f3 knight and attacks white's queen. Pawn to e6 or g6 would probably have been better here. Their queen relocated to the much less active a4 square, but after attacking with my bishop, they went back to d1. Oddly, I did not consider a d1 retreat, but rather a stubborn a3 or a6. Either would have blundered Nc2+. After the retreat, I was not too sure what to play, so capturing their knight and then the recapturing bishop, thus ruining their kingside pawn structure, seemed all right. Instead, they immediately recaptured with the e pawn, which I thought was strange, but could not find a way to punish it. It should be noted that it does leave the d pawn isolated, which would have happened anyway with bishop captures. Perhaps they wanted to keep their strong bishop despite it being blocked? Now that d5 had been weakened, I pushed d5 to make two great pawn chains (position below). After a few captures on d5, I retake with the bishop. This is a slight error on my end, since queen takes would have been better since it pins the f pawn and puts great pressure on the kingside. After more development and black's kingside castles, I consider white's Bb2 to be the end of the opening.
https://lichess.org/study/aksQkSF9/QFRq5MpI#20

Middlegame Analysis

I decided to immediately challenge their dark-squared bishop with Bf6. Instead of taking my f6 bishop, they should have played Bc3 so that if I took, they could deisolate their d pawn. Now with my queen on the strong diagonal, I decided to target their weak d pawn with the rooks. We ended up trading light-squared bishops after white's f4 move (position below). I did not want to have a bishop trapped behind its own pawns while white enjoyed a very good bishop on g2. But I also did not want it on a6, nor did I want the queen dropping back to defend. At worse, two powerful bishops are being traded, which is equal in my eyes. Although, the chess engine wants black to play Bc8, which still confuses me. After the trade, I piled all my major pieces on the poor d pawn.

https://lichess.org/study/aksQkSF9/QFRq5MpI#39

On move 24, I played h6 because I was out of ideas. I wanted to see if white would make a mistake concerning their d pawn. I should have been more active with this position, such as playing a5 or Qf5. Once my queen left the d file, though, they challenged my rook with Rc4, which I captured. The engine recommends R4d6 which truly confuses me. The line it suggests is merely the pieces being shuffled as they struggle for control over the d file without a seemingly actualized plan. Maybe I'm too ignorant to see the purpose of such a move, or it might have to do with the fact that the d pawn is no longer isolated. After the rooks were exchanged on c4, the middlegame is over.

Endgame Analysis

The queens were shuffled around the queenside until we got to the position below. This looks exactly like a beginner puzzle that I'm somewhat ashamed that I did not see it until a few moves later. After my rook captured the free c and a pawn (the d pawn was pinned), black is winning by quite a margin. With two passed pawns and virtually no counterplay from white, it should be an easy win. Alas, only one mistake can lose a game. After targeting the d pawn again (now reisolated), I put my queen on f4 to maybe chase their king. They took the now free g7 pawn with check (position below). Deep down I knew this was a bad move, but I could not think of the proper response. I should have played Qf7, since it threatens their queen and after queen takes and the last rook is taken, Black still has two passed pawns and the black king is closer. If white simply retreats their queen with Qxh6, the rook can save itself with Re2+, and now black is up a full rook. If I had seen this, I would have certainly played it. But I just retreated the king to d6. After they checked my king and threatened to take the e pawn, I just thought, "Well, I'll just protect it." without realizing the skewer threat. And just like that, the game was lost for black.

https://lichess.org/study/aksQkSF9/QFRq5MpI#59

Conclusion

At least I was winning throughout most of the game, so I can confidently say that I get a higher rating. But until then, I'll have to caution myself for the future to always be looking out for counterplay. Here is a link to my study of all my blog-games. Thanks for reading.