Comments on https://lichess.org/@/craze/blog/what-makes-chess-significant/Njxs4KIy
Interesting post.
I tend to believe chess, music, art, etc. have very limited value. Music and art have the ability to appeal the masses. Much writing and art has become a commodity with generative AI, even considering the limits of how it exists in current forms.
Music has proven much harder to commoditize, but generative AI for music is likely coming.
Film is likely long away from generative AI being able to produce quality content.
Again - broad appeal, and difficulty making into a commodity are what makes escapist outlets economically valuable. You can apply to same to sports and other non-essential things.
Chess can be considered a sport, although a less exciting one, and thus has limited entertainment and diplomatic value.
I was really, really bad at chess when I first started a few years back. I was rated 800 in bullet and would have gone even lower if Lichess permitted it at the time. It took me months to reach 1500+ and it's been a slow crawl up ever since.
My experience with chess - from going through the Lichess lessons to learn the basic rules and tactics, to playing puzzles, to learning through intuition - largely agrees with your post.
There are tradeoffs to make in chess. I was going through a severe court case at the time I was learning the game. Once I became better at chess, I became more confident in my ability to face the reality that the court case would likely come with tradeoffs in terms of outcomes. Sometimes you have to give a little in order to take.
Chess has discrete rules, whereas I've always been a more intuitive and "fuzzy" thinker. By playing chess, I've learned how to map my intuitive thinking to things that ultimately require discrete, finite decisions.
I'm sure there are other things I've learned from chess.
Chess will not make you a genius, but getting at least decent at chess will teach you new ways of thinking that have value in the real world.
Interesting post.
I tend to believe chess, music, art, etc. have very limited value. Music and art have the ability to appeal the masses. Much writing and art has become a commodity with generative AI, even considering the limits of how it exists in current forms.
Music has proven much harder to commoditize, but generative AI for music is likely coming.
Film is likely long away from generative AI being able to produce quality content.
Again - broad appeal, and difficulty making into a commodity are what makes escapist outlets economically valuable. You can apply to same to sports and other non-essential things.
Chess can be considered a sport, although a less exciting one, and thus has limited entertainment and diplomatic value.
I was really, really bad at chess when I first started a few years back. I was rated 800 in bullet and would have gone even lower if Lichess permitted it at the time. It took me months to reach 1500+ and it's been a slow crawl up ever since.
My experience with chess - from going through the Lichess lessons to learn the basic rules and tactics, to playing puzzles, to learning through intuition - largely agrees with your post.
There are tradeoffs to make in chess. I was going through a severe court case at the time I was learning the game. Once I became better at chess, I became more confident in my ability to face the reality that the court case would likely come with tradeoffs in terms of outcomes. Sometimes you have to give a little in order to take.
Chess has discrete rules, whereas I've always been a more intuitive and "fuzzy" thinker. By playing chess, I've learned how to map my intuitive thinking to things that ultimately require discrete, finite decisions.
I'm sure there are other things I've learned from chess.
Chess will not make you a genius, but getting at least decent at chess will teach you new ways of thinking that have value in the real world.
In my opinion there is no connection between chess and real life and the reason for that is nowadays chess has become a speed game rather than a thinking game. Most players play these meaningless 1 0 games where the only goal seems to be to move the mouse around faster than the opponent does. There is no strategy or calculation just outspeeding the opponent and I don't see how does that very particular skill can be of particular any use in the real world.
In my opinion there is no connection between chess and real life and the reason for that is nowadays chess has become a speed game rather than a thinking game. Most players play these meaningless 1 0 games where the only goal seems to be to move the mouse around faster than the opponent does. There is no strategy or calculation just outspeeding the opponent and I don't see how does that very particular skill can be of particular any use in the real world.
@Hagredion said in #3:
In my opinion there is no connection between chess and real life and the reason for that is nowadays chess has become a speed game rather than a thinking game. Most players play these meaningless 1 0 games where the only goal seems to be to move the mouse around faster than the opponent does. There is no strategy or calculation just outspeeding the opponent and I don't see how does that very particular skill can be of particular any use in the real world.
Oddly enough, I feel as though I have plenty of time to think in 1+0 games. I try to avoid flagging whenever possible. My goal of every bullet game is checkmate, not flagging the opponent.
It's long games that I feel are a waste of time. Although, I've never played over the board.
Regardless, I feel as though I've learned a lot from chess. You have to actually try to think your way through it, though.
And I find the rapid repetition of various tactics and strategies to be very applicable to solving problems in the real world.
@Hagredion said in #3:
> In my opinion there is no connection between chess and real life and the reason for that is nowadays chess has become a speed game rather than a thinking game. Most players play these meaningless 1 0 games where the only goal seems to be to move the mouse around faster than the opponent does. There is no strategy or calculation just outspeeding the opponent and I don't see how does that very particular skill can be of particular any use in the real world.
Oddly enough, I feel as though I have plenty of time to think in 1+0 games. I try to avoid flagging whenever possible. My goal of every bullet game is checkmate, not flagging the opponent.
It's long games that I feel are a waste of time. Although, I've never played over the board.
Regardless, I feel as though I've learned a lot from chess. You have to actually try to think your way through it, though.
And I find the rapid repetition of various tactics and strategies to be very applicable to solving problems in the real world.
