lichess.org
Donate

offline

Hi,

I am noticing that I have many games where players go offline when I have them in a pinch or when extremly complex positions arise, only to return to make genius moves.

Needless to say I think many of those are Cheating and temporarily switch to an engine! or ChessBase or what have you ...
Can we bring the 'offline counter down to 30 seconds' or keep track of the time periods in which players go offline (eg shown in the graph where moves are displayed in Analyse mode) ?

I'm convinced that this would be an excellent way to avoid some of the cheating that is going on.

One would then need two devices, one for the Game and one for the helpful Engine , making it at least less feasible.

kind regards,
Benny

Hi, I am noticing that I have many games where players go offline when I have them in a pinch or when extremly complex positions arise, only to return to make genius moves. Needless to say I think many of those are Cheating and temporarily switch to an engine! or ChessBase or what have you ... Can we bring the 'offline counter down to 30 seconds' or keep track of the time periods in which players go offline (eg shown in the graph where moves are displayed in Analyse mode) ? I'm convinced that this would be an excellent way to avoid some of the cheating that is going on. One would then need two devices, one for the Game and one for the helpful Engine , making it at least less feasible. kind regards, Benny

I agree with you; I wouldn't say it happens often, but it occurs frequently enough to be bothersome, and it casts doubt on the opponent's fair play. I also considered that shortening the reconnection window might be a good idea, but the issue is that legitimate disconnections can happen to people through no fault of their own. And, unfortunately, cheating will always exist.

I agree with you; I wouldn't say it happens often, but it occurs frequently enough to be bothersome, and it casts doubt on the opponent's fair play. I also considered that shortening the reconnection window might be a good idea, but the issue is that legitimate disconnections can happen to people through no fault of their own. And, unfortunately, cheating will always exist.

The green dot going "offline" doesn't mean that your opponent is cheating at all. Unfortunately many think (as you seem to do) that it indicates cheating but it doesn't.

We moderators have all of the relevant information to help cheat detection so my advice is to try not to be suspicious and to report users who you think might have been cheating. The mods will take care of those who were actually cheating.

I sometimes catch myself being suspicious during a game, only to realize afterwards (and using my moderation tools) that my opponent was definitely not cheating!

I should chill a bit more. We should all do :-)

The green dot going "offline" doesn't mean that your opponent is cheating at all. Unfortunately many think (as you seem to do) that it indicates cheating but it doesn't. We moderators have all of the relevant information to help cheat detection so my advice is to try not to be suspicious and to report users who you think might have been cheating. The mods will take care of those who were actually cheating. I sometimes catch myself being suspicious during a game, only to realize afterwards (and using my moderation tools) that my opponent was definitely not cheating! I should chill a bit more. We should all do :-)

I did not claim going offline = cheating.
However. if someone switches to a different app on eg. a smartphone they would show offline, so it certainly could be an indicator of Cheating.

As an alternative I would like to suggest the option to 'Abort' games when the Opponent goes offline for a certain amount of time (say, 30 seconds).

I did not claim going offline = cheating. However. if someone switches to a different app on eg. a smartphone they would show offline, so it certainly could be an indicator of Cheating. As an alternative I would like to suggest the option to 'Abort' games when the Opponent goes offline for a certain amount of time (say, 30 seconds).

"While your concern about cheating is completely understandable, lowering the offline disconnection timer to 30 seconds or tracking it on a graph may not actually prevent the specific type of cheating you are describing.
Here is why this happens and how online platforms address it:
• Lag and Connection Fluctuations: In many cases, players appearing 'offline' for a few seconds is just a visual sync issue caused by high ping, packet loss, or a temporary browser focus loss (switching tabs). It doesn't necessarily mean they disconnected on purpose.
• The Two-Device Problem: As you mentioned at the end, a player determined to cheat does not need to disconnect or leave the page. They can simply look at a second device (like a phone or tablet) next to their screen while remaining perfectly online on Lichess. Therefore, a shorter disconnection timer wouldn't stop them.
• Lichess Cheat Detection: Lichess doesn't catch cheaters based on whether they go offline. Instead, their anti-cheat system analyzes move quality, accuracy, time spent per move (move times consistency), and how closely the moves match top engine choices. If someone is switching tabs to check ChessBase, their irregular move times will easily trigger the detection system.
Your suggestion to visualize connection stability on a graph is interesting, but reducing the timer to 30 seconds would unfortunately punish innocent players with poor internet connections more than it would stop actual cheaters."

"While your concern about cheating is completely understandable, lowering the offline disconnection timer to 30 seconds or tracking it on a graph may not actually prevent the specific type of cheating you are describing. Here is why this happens and how online platforms address it: • Lag and Connection Fluctuations: In many cases, players appearing 'offline' for a few seconds is just a visual sync issue caused by high ping, packet loss, or a temporary browser focus loss (switching tabs). It doesn't necessarily mean they disconnected on purpose. • The Two-Device Problem: As you mentioned at the end, a player determined to cheat does not need to disconnect or leave the page. They can simply look at a second device (like a phone or tablet) next to their screen while remaining perfectly online on Lichess. Therefore, a shorter disconnection timer wouldn't stop them. • Lichess Cheat Detection: Lichess doesn't catch cheaters based on whether they go offline. Instead, their anti-cheat system analyzes move quality, accuracy, time spent per move (move times consistency), and how closely the moves match top engine choices. If someone is switching tabs to check ChessBase, their irregular move times will easily trigger the detection system. Your suggestion to visualize connection stability on a graph is interesting, but reducing the timer to 30 seconds would unfortunately punish innocent players with poor internet connections more than it would stop actual cheaters."

Well aware of people having unstable connections.
What I wonder about , however, are Opponents having stable connections for long times seemingly until crucial phases in the game occure.

So why not give the option to Abort the game when your Opponent goes offline for e.g. 30 seconds.
Seems fair to both players, the one (potentially) struggling with his connection (and losing time, possibly Game) would not mind the Abort if he/she is truly fighting lag and potentially losing the game because of it.

Well aware of people having unstable connections. What I wonder about , however, are Opponents having stable connections for long times seemingly until crucial phases in the game occure. So why not give the option to Abort the game when your Opponent goes offline for e.g. 30 seconds. Seems fair to both players, the one (potentially) struggling with his connection (and losing time, possibly Game) would not mind the Abort if he/she is truly fighting lag and potentially losing the game because of it.

I had a game recently where the opponent went offline for every move in the game!, as it happens i did in fact lose that game, but it surely isn't the type of behaviour that we should have to accept as ok, especially when we have no way to ease our suspicion by checking to see if they are possibly cheating somehow, as we have no moderating tools at our disposal, and so we just get annoyed by this lack of etiquette as much as anything else by our opponent constantly disappearing then turning up again and instantly playing their move and going offline again. :)

I had a game recently where the opponent went offline for every move in the game!, as it happens i did in fact lose that game, but it surely isn't the type of behaviour that we should have to accept as ok, especially when we have no way to ease our suspicion by checking to see if they are possibly cheating somehow, as we have no moderating tools at our disposal, and so we just get annoyed by this lack of etiquette as much as anything else by our opponent constantly disappearing then turning up again and instantly playing their move and going offline again. :)

Yet another case of selective perception that gradually builds up.

Yet another case of selective perception that gradually builds up.

Cheating is so common and easy that it makes you paranoid—and that’s only natural...

Cheating is so common and easy that it makes you paranoid—and that’s only natural...

@kanou219 said ^

Cheating is so common and easy that it makes you paranoid—and that’s only natural...

It's not even that common ... the fear is common ...

It may be easy, but then it's even easier to get banned fast ...

@kanou219 said [^](/forum/redirect/post/8uFVXKyU) > Cheating is so common and easy that it makes you paranoid—and that’s only natural... It's not even *that* common ... the fear is common ... It may be easy, but then it's even easier to get banned fast ...